Clinical Care

Shrimp Burgers, Night Clinic and Canine Rescue: Celebrating a Career Devoted to Caring for Migrant Farmworkers

Article from Streamline, November - December, Issue: Volume 16, Issue 6

PHOTO: Caroloyn Davis FNP 2010

MCN- Carolyn Davis, Family Nurse Practitioner, was awarded the Steve Shore Community Catalyst Award at the 2010 East Coast Migrant Stream Forum that took place in Charleston, SC, in October of this year. I first met Carolyn in 1997, when a group of us at MCN embarked on an epic journey in a rented RV from Austin, Texas to Ashville, North Carolina for another East Coast Migrant Stream Forum. I was five months pregnant with my first child, my husband was the volunteer driver, and along with three other women from the staff we set off for a two-week tour of health centers in seven southeastern states.

Our adventures were nearly halted in Eutaw, Alabama, when we realized that the shoestring operation we’d used to rent the RV didn’t actually have insurance that covered us. But our intrepid leader, Karen Mountain, figured out some way around that hurdle from her post in Austin and we continued eastward.

Every stop along the way was unique and we were awed by the creativity and dedication we witnessed at each subsequent health center. On day six we rolled into Beaufort, South Carolina, a bit road weary and overwhelmed by all we had seen. We parked our monstrous RV in the parking lot of Beaufort Jasper Hampton Comprehensive Health Services, Inc. and were met in the waiting room by the Migrant Health Coordinator, Carolyn Davis, the most gracious and enthusiastic person we had yet encountered in a trip full of wonderful people. Carolyn took one look at us and declared us in dire need of the best local fare. We followed her out through the beautiful flat coastal lowlands to a hole-in-thewall on the dock called The Shrimp Shack. The “Shack” specializes in shrimp burgers made from the fresh catch hauled onto the dock daily. Unfortunately they will not reveal their recipe, but to this day that is one of the best meals I have ever had.

Beaufort Jasper Hampton Comprehensive Health Services, Inc. is located in the midst of the “low country” of South Carolina. This is a beautiful part of the United States; a land of spreading moss-covered oak trees, palmettos and thousands of acres of stately southern pine. The marshy coastal region is made up of many small islands, including exclusive resort islands such as Hilton Head. From her home on a nearby island, Carolyn can hear the guns from the Marine training grounds on the neighboring Parris Island.

This region is also known for its agriculture, particularly for tomatoes and watermelon in the summer with winter vegetable crops such as winter squash, collard greens and sweet potatoes. Unlike some other regions of the country, the crops in this area of South Carolina are still largely worked by migrant farmworkers, many of whom travel up from Florida, others of whom come from Mexico, Central America, or Texas. Most of the migrants in this region are Hispanic families and young single people; however there is still a contingent of Haitian workers who primarily work in the packing sheds. Once the picking season is over in the Beaufort Jasper area, many of the same farmworkers travel further north to the Delmarva Peninsula where the season begins a couple of months later.

While agricultural employment has remained stable in this region, in recent years many migrants have also found work in the booming construction industry, particularly in the upscale resorts of the barrier islands. The increase in luxury housing on the barriers islands has moved more of the agricultural production inland. As Carolyn says, the islands now “grow more condos then veggies”.

Carolyn Davis did not start her career with the intention of working with migrant farmworkers. The daughter of a career Navy man, she moved regularly as a child, graduating from high school in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. She received an associate degree in nursing from Florida Junior College, eventually graduating from the University of South Carolina with a BA and a Masters in Nursing. At that point she went to work for the local county hospital where she was the Director of Nursing.

In the early 1980’s, for a variety of reasons, Carolyn was looking for a change. She decided to explore the world of community health and left her job with the hospital to work for Beaufort Jasper Hampton Comprehensive Health Services, Inc. At the time she was unaware that there were even migrants in the area. The only thing she knew was that during the summer months hospital emergency room staff saw a jump in the number of people coming in. It took her only eight weeks to fall in love with the work and she has worked as the director of the migrant health program since that time. In addition to being the Migrant Health Coordinator, Carolyn was also
appointed the Director of Nursing for the health center. In the mid-90’s Carolyn went back to school and received her family nurse practitioner degree from the Medical University of South Carolina.

PHOTO: Carolyn Davis and ClientThe migrant health program at Beaufort Jasper has grown tremendously and now serves farmworkers from three counties and a large number of migrant camps. The program runs year-round, but the biggest push comes during the 6-8 weeks of harvest time when there is a large influx of migrant workers. During this time, Carolyn brings in many different professionals from the community and the clinic to provide a wide array of services to the migrant patients. Most of these services are provided during the night clinic where they have seen as many as 87 people in one night. Carolyn says that the night clinic is “controlled chaos that somehow works”. She typically has people lining up to work in the migrant program long before the season begins.

In addition to the clinic time, Carolyn runs a number of outreach efforts in the migrant camps throughout the region. Outreach in the camps includes health education, screenings and mini physicals. When doing outreach, Carolyn often serves a number of different roles including advocacy, screening and referrals for further care.

One night a health center outreach worker called Carolyn in a panic to say that some of the farmworkers had been attacked by several members of the community. Carolyn drove out to the camp to investigate the situation and determined that everyone was safe and not badly injured. While there the farmworkers gave her a dog that had been traveling with them since Florida. She named the dog Dempsi, after the camp where the farmworkers had been living. Since that time she has rescued several other dogs from the camps.

Carolyn says that over the course of her career some things have improved for the migrant population while others have worsened. She believes that some of the prevention messages have made a real impact, especially in decreasing rates of sexually transmitted diseases and acute pesticide poisonings. At the same time, the migrants she sees continue to suffer from a number of musculoskeletal problems, dehydration and fatigue. Additionally, she sees more and more chronic disease, mirroring what is happening throughout the rest of the country, except that the patients she treats are often sicker and harder to manage. Finding specialty care is particularly difficult and Carolyn has to employ a number of different strategies to get people into care that they need.

A positive development has been the health center’s increasing use of MCN’s Health Network to help manage and track mobile patients. Carolyn says that Health Network “is a must for all of our diabetic patients, people with tuberculosis, our prenatal patients and anyone we screen for cancer.” In the past Carolyn says that she would have put off doing a mammogram for a woman she knew would be traveling soon, but since the advent of Health Network she knows that she will be able to find the woman and get her in care if necessary. Rosa Navarro, from the North Carolina Community Health Center Association (NCCHCA) tells the following story about Carolyn.

”When for any reason, she gets discouraged, she looks for a tree. Looking at a tree reminds her of one of the many individuals she has served. In 1986 during an evening clinic, a week before a group of farmworkers were scheduled to leave South Carolina, the physician noticed that a young man was having difficulty seeing. A visual test and health history revealed that he was almost blind and had been that way since childhood. He was able to work because he learned to use his other senses and because he had help from his co-workers. She remembered securing immediate, free consultation with an ophthalmologist by working with a local church to pay for glasses. When the young man used his eyeglasses, for the first time he noted the large object outside the window and exclaimed ‘tree’! This was the first time he had actually seen one in its entirety. Because he had never seen clearly in his life, he even had difficulty walking. Carolyn held his hand as he took his first unsteady steps. The sense of accomplishment has never abandoned Carolyn, because she believes that if she can help one person to see a tree for a first time, she can certainly line up the stars again to increase access and continuity of care for other farmworkers.”

Join Discussion »

Be Informed and Educate Others on National Latino AIDS Awareness Day

BANNER: Save a Life. It may be your own. National AIDS Awareness Day.HIV/AIDS takes an especially heavy toll on the most vulnerable and marginalized groups in US society. Poverty, low income, limited education, sub-standard housing, and limited access to health care are all factors that increase the rate of HIV/AIDS in a population. Farmworkers in the US contend with all these risk factors, plus others: limited English proficiency, mobile lifestyle, and social isolation, to mention but a few. This confluence of social and economic risk factors creates a situation in which a serious HIV/AIDS outbreak is a distinct possibility 

An outbreak would be particularly devastating for a population already vulnerable due to minimal physical and financial resources and poorer health status than the general population. At present, the seroprevalence rate of HIV/AIDS in farmworker communities is unknown. The vast majority of the epidemiological data on HIV incidence among farmworkers is based on small, local studies. A 1992 study of 310 farmworkers in Immokalee, FL, by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found an HIV positive prevalence rate of 5%, almost 10 times that of the national rate of 0.6% at the time. A few other small studies reported have reported rates ranging from 0.47% to 13% .

In the absence of adequate population-based data on farmworkers, useful inferences may be drawn from statistics collected on migrant Latinos in the US, a group known to be disproportionately affected and infected by HIV. HIV/AIDS cases among Latinos are increasing in both incidence and prevalence . Latinos comprise approximately 13% of the US population, but account for 16% of all AIDS cases since the onset of the epidemic. Additionally, approximately 19% of all newly-diagnosed cases in the US are among Latinos.

For more information about HIV within underserved populations:

Join Discussion »

Dr. Zuroweste Reports from the Field

I was amazed today to be copied on an email about a big concern about the emergency response of the influenza team in Eastern Europe. I was copied because of the possibility that we may need to quickly mobilize a training of rural providers on the recognition and treatment of the potential severe complications of H1N1.

It is rather fascinating now how the world has become smaller and smaller and that communications are so rapid that literally on a daily basis we are getting very accurate reports of severe outbreaks in small communities all over the world.

I have also been present for some very high level discussions about how much where resources should be deployed. Like any other large organization it is astonishing to see that at WHO sometimes petty politics and personalities get in the way of rational evidence based science and humanitarian response.

I just found out that I will be presenting the results of our training efforts and the concept of the Clinicians Manual at an annual clinical meeting of the Asian component of the WHO in Manila in about 10 days and will also be doing a full day training of the manual at the IUATLD in Cancun in December. It also amazes me how in just 2 months they have managed to insert me into a very responsible role here and I see the same thing happening with my colleagues especially this incredible family physician from South Africa who has only been here since June after 23 years on the front lines in the "bush" dealing with a population with almost a 40% HIV positive rate and tons of MDR and now XDRTB.

Join Discussion »

Concentrated Animal Feeding Operators at Greater Risk for H1N1?

There is great concern from clinicians we talk to that many of the migrants we serve, specifically those who work for large agricultural companies that raise and slaughter pigs and chickens (CAFOs-- concentrated animal feeding operations) are at high risk for not only contracting H1N1 but also because of frequent migration and crowded living conditions they are likely to spread the virus rapidly. Even a greater “theoretical concern” that we have is that these workers may be a source of new novel more virulent strains of the H1N1 virus because of their constant daily close exposure to pigs and chickens. We have tried to explain to the CDC, NIOSH, OSHA that this group of workers should be in the category of “high risk” and therefore eligible for both early vaccine and treatment if illness occurs.

Unfortunately, we have been unsuccessful for a variety of reasons. This population, as you probably know, are for the vast majority, recent immigrants and frequently undocumented. So, it is always “controversial” when we try to highlight this population.

A recent article: http://www.ehponline.org/members/2009/117-9/focus.html more completely describes many of my concerns.

Join Discussion »

Innovation More Important Than Ever

It often seems that the most innovative programs develop out of the most hopeless seeming situations. The world of migrant health is full of examples of individuals who see a great need and then employ creative thinking and action to right a wrong. In a world where we too often run up against an intractable bureaucracy, these examples of creative problem solving are a breath of fresh air. Some of the most inspired thinking in migrant health comes out of the 22 Migrant Voucher Programs that exist nationwide. All of the voucher programs coordinate, facilitate, and provide access to primary health care for farmworkers by purchasing, rather than providing directly, some or all of the primary care services required. In many ways these voucher programs are one of the best models for public-private partnerships found in primary care for the underserved. As Susan Bauer, Executive Director for Community Health Partnerships of Illinois says, “When vouchers come to town, private providers become partners in our health systems and we gain extree into the wider community of support for migrants”. As economic times get more difficult, imagination in health care is even more important to reach out to the hardest to treat among us. You can find out more about these programs here.

Join Discussion »

Community Health Centers Demonstrate Malpractice Coverage Success!

In 1992, Congress passed legislation for HRSA through the Bureau of Primary Health Care to institute a Federal Government Self-insured malpractice program that was named “Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA program). Since its inception in 1992 there has now been an estimated cost savings of $1.6 BILLION. That means that this money has been poured back into health centers and healthcare for the poor instead of to the very profitable malpractice insurance companies.

I wonder what would happen if the US had a healthcare system based on CHCs where all providers were covered by FTCA??? How many health care dollars would then be diverted from private malpractice insurance and into healthcare for all!!!!!!

From 2002-2007 the number of claims per million patient encounters has decreased from 6.2 to 3.8 which is a remarkable 38% DECREASE!!!

There has also been a steady growth in cost savings each of the past 5 years ($164 million in 2002 to $193 million in 2007). This has all been accomplished “during a period of time when the demands of increased exposure stemming from higher patient volume and greater complexity of care delivery”.

FTCA helps all of us when we are out there selling a career in migrant/community health centers. We can now truly state that this malpractice insurance (FTCA) is the best malpractice insurance a provider can have. Why?? Because it costs the health center and provider nothing, there is no upper limit to the claim so there is no liability at all to the providers and there is no time limit on your coverage (you are covered for life for all of the time you were covered by FTCA at your health center (i.e. no “tail coverage” necessary). And if you are unfortunate enough to be involved in a malpractice case you will be defended in Federal Court by an expert Federal Malpractice Attorney.

Join Discussion »

Authentic Voices

MCN is pleased to offer these five audio slideshows featuring farmworkers and health care providers. We want to hear your thoughts. What did these slideshows make you think about that you may not have previously considered?

Join Discussion »

Make a Commitment to Healthcare Justice in 2008!

Join a gathering of clinicians from across the country and show your unity with the uninsured, underinsured, and marginalized people across our nation. We are very excited to be a part of the National Summit of Clinicians for Healthcare Justice, a one of a kind event sponsored by many of the major safety-net clinician organizations across the United States. The 2 ½ day event is expected to attract at least 500 clinicians and advocates who will come together to celebrate, acknowledge and highlight the work frontline clinicians do to serve disenfranchised populations in need of basic healthcare in our country. To find out more go to www.allclinicians.org.

Join Discussion »

Misplaced Compassion?

I have the great privilege of visiting over 20 migrant and community health centers every year. I am consistently impressed with the quality and dedication I see among health center clinicians. As a rule, clinicians working in federally funded health centers are individuals who highly value compassionate primary care. There are times however, when I see misconceptions among clinicians about what best serves the clinic and in turn, the patients. A common problem I see is clinicians undercoding a patient visit because he or she thinks that this will help the uninsured patient to pay less for that service. While this is very well intentioned, the trouble is that undercoding undermines the ability for health centers to document the true extent of their populations’ need. Without that documentation health centers have a much harder time raising funds that in turn help those patients most destitute. Is this an issue you see in your health center? If so, have you done anything to address it?

Join Discussion »

Mercury injections?

I recently read an article about the ritual use of mercury in immigrant populations. It jumped out at me because this is an issue that Venkat Prasad, MD, the medical director at Tri-County Community Health Center, has seen in his health center. A couple of years ago, Dr. Prasad wrote about a case of two recently arrived immigrants from Honduras who used mercury injections to ward off evil as they made their journey across the border ( Env. Health Persp. Vol 112, Num 13, Sept 2004 or MCN’s reprint in Streamline). The use of mercury to bring good luck is not uncommon for practitioners of Santeria. When used for good luck, small amounts of mercury are sprinkled in and around homes and cars. Mercury injections are a less common phenomenon. The extent of the ritual use of mercury is not well documented, but a few cases of injected mercury have come to the attention of clinicians. Exposure to mercury (regardless of the route) is problematic, but the injections are far more serious. Most recently a Mexican women required surgery and suffered a severe infection from a mercury injection to help lift her luck as undocumented immigrant. (see the article in the Trentonian) The Santatarian priest who gave her the injection has been jailed. This is one more example of the unique issues we face as migrant health clinicians and how important it is to keep an open mind about patient symptoms.

Join Discussion »

Syndicate content